Chatham High School seniors Ishar Swamy, Viktor Fishman, and junior Taran Wadhera recently earned first place in the International LegalEagleBee Legal Defense Global Challenge, tackling their legal expertise beyond the school competition circuit.
Swamy initially discovered the competition while browsing Instagram, having previously participated in the organization’s court case competition. Recognizing the opportunity to further develop their courtroom skills beyond CHS’s Mock Trial team, he shared the competition with Fishman and Wadhera.
“We thought it’d be a great idea,” Swamy said, explaining that the competition would also help the group prepare for the upcoming mock trial season.
Hosted by LegalEagleBee, the Legal Defense Global Challenge is an international competition where high school and college students take on the role of defense attorneys in simulated legal cases. Students can compete individually or in teams of up to three, choosing from cases involving white-collar crime, civil liability, or constitutional law. The competition consists of two rounds, beginning with a written submission in which participants examine evidence and develop a defense strategy to explain their approach to the case. The top 10 percent of teams then advance to the second round, where they must present their arguments in a three- to four-minute video.
The team selected a case involving the defense of an AI startup founder accused of criminal wire fraud and algorithm theft after the failure of a major system, assuming the roles of defense attorneys.
“We all kind of played attorneys,” Fishman explained. “We all were kind of working together as a defense team for the corporation.”
For the first round, the students were required to produce an approximately 10- to 11-page legal brief examining constitutional questions surrounding police conduct and outlining how they would defend their client in court. Completing the brief, however, proved to be more challenging than anticipated.
“I think the time constraint was probably the biggest struggle for us,” Wadhera recalled. ”When we submitted the first portion, we knew that only the top 10% of teams were allowed to advance to the second part. We initially got the dates wrong for when it was due, so we were scrambling to finish the paper.” Swamy further explained.
Despite the pressure, the team’s efforts earned them approximately 97 out of 100 points in the first round, placing them among the top 10 percent of participating teams and securing their advancement to the next stage.
The second round challenged the students to transform their written legal arguments into a video presentation. In addition to the substance of their analysis, competitors were evaluated on their delivery and effectiveness in communicating their case. Surprisingly, the team recorded its presentation in essentially one take, without anticipating that the submission would ultimately earn the competition’s highest distinction.
Outside the competition, all three students are active members of the CHS mock trial team, where Swamy serves as the club president and Wadhera as vice president. Beyond mock trial, Wadhera is also involved in competitive speech and debate, ranking among the top 15 in the nation for public forum debate and qualifying for national tournaments multiple times. Fishman, meanwhile, has spent the past two years taking on the role of a witness in several mock trial competitions. He also participated in American Legion Jersey Boys State, a selective, weeklong program where high school students learn about government and civic leadership. They are also all interested in pursuing public policy and political science in college.
Although the trio initially entered the competition as a way to prepare for the upcoming mock trial season, their first-place finish marked an unexpected achievement. With their shared interest in law and government, Swamy, Fishman, and Wadhera hope to continue building on their experiences both inside and outside the courtroom.
For the full list of finalists and winners, visit LegalEagleBee’s official results page.
