It’s mid-November, and almost everyone is munching on their well-deserved haul of delicious candy. Over 745 million pounds of candy were given out to kids all over the U.S., and over 100 types of candy have been collected by trick-or-treaters. Now it’s time to find out which candies ranked the highest in the satisfaction category and some of the most popular and rarest candies collected by trick-or-treaters this 2026 Halloween season.
Popularity Rankings
These candies are the most popular for 2026, ranked by various food websites.
(Food & Wine, Thrillist, Tasting Table)
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
- Snickers
- M&M’s
- Kit Kat
- Twix
- Skittles
- Sour Patch Kids
- Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bars
- Milky Way
10.) Haribo Goldbears
In this article, I will touch on some of the most popular candies located on this list of rankings.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Once again, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups have dominated Halloween candy rankings, being an undisputed #1 in all of the U.S. Almost everyone has a feel for the sweet and salty combination, along with the scrumptious milk chocolate coating.
M&M’s
This year, M&M’s came 3rd in the Halloween rankings, falling behind Snickers and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. There was some surprise this year, as M&M’s tend to rank 2nd or 1st in most popular candies. Nevertheless, both the peanut and chocolate flavors were still in high demand, a classic for sharing and snacking with friends and family.
Kit Kat
Kit Kat had what one would say a “big hype,” with many looking forward to devouring this delicious wafer chocolate. Personally, I love Kit Kat and would eat any bit of the easy-to-break bar along with its crunchy texture. While the candy placed 4th on the list, it definitely scored first for some chocolate enthusiasts and trick-or-treaters.
Skittles
Skittles had a similar story to M&M’s. For the last few years, the candy had placed in the top 3 multiple times. This year, the fruity chew candy placed 6th. While a favorite among kids, the main reason this candy could not compete with the other chocolates was due to multiple published articles by numerous doctors regarding the dangers of eating a chewy candy with dyes hidden in it. This factor does make a possible explanation for why this candy ranked a bit lower than usual.
Haribo Goldbears
Rounding out the final spot are the iconic Haribo gummy bears. Usually not making the cut, these gummy bears took over Butterfingers in the rankings and claimed the last place on the list. However, depending on the region in the U.S., some parts gave out more Haribo Goldbears than others. One thing I know for sure is that here in Chatham, NJ, multiple trick-or-treaters reported a high collection of Haribo Goldbears.
Miscellaneous
After breaking down some of the most popular candies out there, chocolate candies dominated regular candies 7-3 on the top 10 list. Other candies that almost made the list were Starbursts, Nerds, Tootsie Pops, and Rolos. In the next part of this article, I will be discussing the rarest candies collected by Trick or Treaters. Check if you have some of the rarest candies in the region!
Rarity Rankings
While there is no official 2026 list of rankings for the rarest candies collected, there are a few unique candies that only a certain number of trick-or-treaters have reported collecting.
Banana Laffy Taffy
Banana Laffy Taffy makes the spot mainly because the candy is rarely handed out in bulk and is usually not available at your regular CVS or other places where people purchase candy for Halloween. Compared to the other fruit chews, Laffy Taffy was ranked very low on the popularity charts, causing it to be uncommon for trick-or-treaters to find.
100 Grand
Depending on the specific region, 100 Grand was a bit more uncommon this year, with less popularity revolving around the caramel chocolate bar. Mainly due to low stock and lower shelf priority compared to other bigger candy stores, 100 Grand has become a bit harder to find this Halloween season.
Hi-Chew
Hi-Chew was very popular in the U.S. in the early 2020s, but after spiking popularity in Japan, Hi-Chews seemed to have been a lot rarer in the U.S. In general, less than 30% of Americans reported getting Hi-Chew candy in past Halloweens.
Smarties
Due to the company having low candy sales, Smarties has become less popular throughout these past few years. Not being in high stock in regular candy supply stores, reports of finding Smarties on Halloween have dropped significantly.
Candy Corn
From being one of the most popular candies in the world, to less than 20% of Americans reporting getting candy corn whilst trick-or-treating, Candy corn rounds out this list. Being one of the most common Halloween candies, candy corn has had quite the falloff, with 66% of Americans “disliking” and even “hating” candy corn texture and flavor. Low sales reports caused a shortage of the candy, meaning that if you got this candy this Halloween, you may have collected one of the rarest Halloween candies of 2026!
Despite popular belief and whether a candy is rare or not, everyone has a specific choice of candy. The real question is: What’s yours?
